Grading: Let's talk about the 79.8%
@Don Sturm’s #Rounding Up post asked something deceptively simple: a 79.8% on a 90-100 scale… do you round up? Eighteen comments later, and we still didn’t quite agree, which of course is understandable. And Don’s earlier post, # Grades and the Meaning of Learning accumulated 42 comments and counting, which tells us this is a conversation we should come back to every so often.
And it's not just us. The national research on grading right now reveals that the conversation is shifting from did they get the material they needed to what does the grade actually mean. This is not a new concept by any stretch, but the influx of AI has made it absolutely top of mind. As a result, competency-based grading and mastery learning keep showing up as 2026 priorities. But in real classrooms, parents and colleges seem to still want the A, B, C - even when we know it's not capturing what a student actually learned.
Which is what makes @Rimmey's Lesson Library post worth surfacing:#Gofundme as a Mastery Check? is actually a persuasive writing assessment. Real audience, real stakes, real feedback, but no rubric required. If grades measure compliance more than learning - and a lot of us suspect they do - what does assessment increasingly look like when you take the grade out entirely?
So: what have you tried that is something like Rimmey's idea? Do you have assessments with a real audience and purpose and no grade attached, and what happened when you tried to explain it to a parent or an admin (if you did)?